Student scores victory over top law firm

by Chris Johnson. Published Wed 13 May 2009 11:09, Last updated: 2009-05-13
Ashokvardhan Purohit
Ashokvardhan Purohit

A law student single-handedly took-on a top legal firm and won a landmark ruling that will open-up British job vacancies to foreign applicants.

The case won by banking studies graduate Ash Purohit means UK firms must now consider all candidates on merit, even if they lack a UK work permit.

Indian-born Mr Purohit took commercial law firm Osborne Clarke Services (OCS) to an Employment Tribunal and a claim for race discrimination.

He then defended that victory at the Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT) in a case that now sets a marker for all other UK companies.

Mr Purohit, who was born in Jodhpur and raised in Mumbai, has an MA in Banking and Finance from Sheffield Hallam University and is currently studying law at a BPP college in the UK.

He first took OCS to an Employment Tribunal after discovering the firm operated a blanket ban on applications, for trainee positions, from anyone without a UK work permit.

He had applied for post as a trainee solicitor with OCS In June 2007 but was shocked to discover that it would not even be considered because of his immigration status.

The company rejected his application citing its policy debarring candidates from outside the European Economic Area (EEA) saying it would not apply for work permits on their behalf.

Purohit lodged two claims, one for direct race discrimination and the second for indirect race discrimination, both on the grounds of nationality. He won the indirect discrimination claim.

OCS appealed but the EAT has dismissed that appeal and the victory means that all non-EEA nationals seeking job in UK now have a right to be considered in the selection process.

However, new regulations introduced last November - while the OCS appeal was in process - add further complications to the issue.

Ashokvardhan Purohit said: "I had completed my undergraduate in Chemistry and Industrial Chemistry, and studied law part-time in India before I came to the UK to study.

"Having completed a Masters in Banking and Finance from Sheffield Hallam University, I am now studying at BPP Law School. . I am particularly interested in working in the field of mergers and acquisitions

"My understanding on this issue was that, employers on their necessarily high screening criteria, were going to select the best candidate via open competition for the job and then based on that selection, make an application for a work permit to the UK Border Agency.

"However, I was disappointed to see that, some of the leading law firms like OCS were using the work permit requirement to segregate and reject applications for non EEA nation candidates.

"When I applied to OCS I wanted to be considered for employment on merit but I discovered the company operated a blanket ban against candidates without a work permit.

"I felt this was discrimination on grounds of race and therefore challenged it at the Employment Tribunal.

"I wasn't sure what to expect about the outcome of the case as I knew that it was going to be difficult.

"The policy of rejecting applications of non-EEA Nationals has been adopted by employers in all sectors in the UK for decades.

"These were recruitment procedures and policies guided and drafted by some of the greatest legal brains and leading law firms.

"But now I have proved it is discriminating since I am the first person to challenge this procedure.

"In fact I tried to seek advice from my law tutors and contacted leading law firms to assist me to fight this uphill battle.

"But everyone kept on telling me that, this was impossible and no-one offered to take on my case.

"I was even told by some people that as a non-EEA national I had no right to take a case to the Employment Tribunal.

"Fortunately I had the moral support of my parents and I worked alone on this case.

"It must admit it was really challenging and demanding and it has taken its toll on me.

"I brought this case, with the intention of fighting for my right and for the rights of all the other non-EEA Nationals who want to apply for the jobs over here in the UK.

"I hope the ruling means that the selection procedures are now going to be based on merit and intellect so the best person can get the job via open competition.

"I'm pleased this decision has gone in my favour.

"It is clear that firms had been misinterpreting the law and government policies and a vast majority of employers were using the excuse of the lack of a work permit to reject applications from non-EEA Nationals.

"The were using the UK Borders Agency as a shield for acts of discrimination.

"It was very daunting to take on a big firm like OCS but it was a matter of principle and I am glad that the tribunal and the EAT recognised the validity of my case."

Osborne Clarke said it changed its policy in light of the original Employment Tribunal's ruling. The Company now considers applications for training contracts from candidates of all nationalities, candidates are not asked if they require work permits until they are offered a position with the Company.

All offers of employment are still conditional on the candidates' ability to obtain a work permit, and Osborne Clarke Services will apply for this on the candidates' behalf as a sponsor if they are successful in their application.

A spokesman for Osborne Clarke Services said: "We are disappointed that the Employment Appeal Tribunal ruled against us on the issue of indirect discrimination.

"We believed that, given the significant volumes of EEA applicants for our trainee scheme, we would be unable to satisfy the Government's strict resident worker requirements for granting work permits to foreign nationals.

"As such, our policy was to not consider any trainee applicant who would require a work permit in order to work lawfully in the UK.

"Osborne Clarke takes its responsibilities as an employer very seriously and we constantly strive to ensure our policies and practices do not discriminate either directly or indirectly in any area of our business.

"In light of the ruling, we have already re-assessed our position on this issue to ensure that our policy complies with the original tribunal's ruling."





Comments about Student scores victory over top law firm

I had the chance to talk to him last week in person. A visionary indeed, now reading about what he has done, feel privileged to have met him
Keeley, does not matter around 4 days, 2 hours ago
This is a great opportunity created for all non EEA Nationals. Congrtulations Mr. Ash and thank you teaching them the law and a good article
Saira, UK around 3 weeks, 5 days ago
Thanks to you Mr.Ash its only because of your Intellegence and unselfish efforts that I have been able to get a job in my field on my merits
Barkha Khan, London around 2 months, 2 weeks ago
I can't thank Ash enough for what he has done by fighting for everyone. Only because of his hard efforts today I have got a job on my merits
Saira, leeds around 2 months, 3 weeks ago
I remember seeing Mr. Ash in action at the tribunal he is an astute speaker,thorough knowledge of law,very polite and humble, Kudos Mr. Ash
Liz, London around 2 months, 4 weeks ago
I think all the law firms should start their training contract working under Mr.Ash,as we need fresh minds to think clear and understand law
Laura, York around 3 months ago
I study law and my mates found this case,it took us 3 weeks to understand its implications and Mr.Ash did it alone. I want to work for him
Samantha, Brisbane, Australia around 3 months ago
It require an individual to be of sharp intellect to change the course of an activity in history. Mr. Ash you are a revolutionary and leader
Samantha, Brisbane, Australia around 3 months ago
I am impressed by the level of intellect used in this case. How do we get in touch with Mr. Ash, It would be an honour to be in his company
Arika, Brisbane, Australia around 3 months ago
Everyone fights for their own rights, Mr. Ash has fought single handed and opened opportunities for everyone who is non-EEA.He is a LEGEND
Mike, Leeds around 3 months ago
Thanks dude for opening a realm of opportunities for individuals who dream big and wish to achieve em. Your victory has helped all of us!
Mithun , Sheffield around 3 months ago
My 1st impression of this suave dude was that he always meant BUSINESS.WHen I learnt abt this achievement it only solidified my perception.
Mithun , Sheffield around 3 months ago
opportunities dnt come ur way...they r created...n u created it 4 millions..dats heroic...congrats ash(bhaisaab)
aj, mumbai around 3 months, 1 week ago
It has been established by Mr.Ash that companies have been discriminating in the aid of BIA. Mr. Ash you are Brilliant to have understood it
Tim, Glasgow around 3 months, 1 week ago
This case means the Resident Labour Market Test used by BIA & companies is never going to be a justified reason for employer to discriminate
Tim, Glasgow around 3 months, 1 week ago
Dost. Do I need to day something.. Extremely Brilliant..
ashish, sheffield around 3 months, 1 week ago
Attended a presentation about this case... this guy has a great way of interpreting the law.Seems like law firms have a lot to learn frm him
steven harding, london around 3 months, 1 week ago
I used to study law with Ash and always knew that he was going to do something Big in History, he has proven from his intellect,luv you m8.x
ella johnson, manchester around 3 months, 1 week ago
I heard about this news and have been looking for it everywhere, seems like the british media are scared of this news and Ash. Congrats Ash
Shweta Gupta, Mumbai around 3 months, 2 weeks ago
Studying with Ash, I realized one thing, looking at the confidence in Ash's eyes,anyone could believe they can achieve anything & everything
Fotis Germanous, Athens around 6 months, 1 week ago
Swati is correct, Ash has united the countries not through land, money and gold, but through his Mind! Thus opening opportunity to all in UK
Fotis Germanous, Athens around 6 months, 1 week ago
There was Gandhi who worked for the benefit of all Indians, and now Mr.Ash who has worked for the benefits of the entire nonEEA nationals.
Swati, Mumbai around 8 months ago
This is another example to show the dicriminating policy practiced widely within the system. Congratulations to Mr.Ash.
Gemma, Newcastle around 8 months ago
fantastic work mate,but i still believe best is still to come,u just made it easy and level plying field for all intl students
inderjit singh sandhu, sheffield around 8 months, 1 week ago
A Big big big victory for all non EEA Nationals, Heartiest Congrats to Ash for bringing the system on the floor. Ur a Genius indeed Mr.Ash.
Power to the People, Slough around 8 months, 2 weeks ago
I never imagined that,he would single handedly prove it as per Britains own law.He is a Man of his word,very sharp, intelligent person
Shabana, Manchester around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
It made sense, however, I found it hard to accept and believe that, top law firms would be wrong about such a discriminating practice
Shabana, Manchester around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I remember meeting Ash in Manchester and he told me tht this practice adopted by employers to discriminate against all non-EEA was not right
Shabana, Manchester around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
A Well written article,a highly complicated case and demonstration of supreme intelligence. Nearly all top law firms are writing about Ash
Racheal, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I am not sure if everyone is aware, NHS employers have changed their recruitment policy with immediate effect thanks to Mr.Ash,Well Done Sir
Sean, Luton around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
How did he manage to beat a top law firm, that means Ash is better than them, we should be thinking that what he has done is as per our law.
Dave, Newcastle around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Another nail in the coffin for the indiginous Brit. What have we done to deserve this?
John Hargrieves, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I think this Ash guy is a genius. He has single handedly removed the phrase British Jobs for British Workers and made it open for the best.
JT, Sheffield around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
British jobs for British workers.
Peter, Liverpool around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
You could not get away with this in other countries. Even the Netherlands makes it hard for non Dutch applicants. I feel angry about this
Hate racism but this is over the top, Scotland around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Great job Ash! It is about time someone challenged this.
Tracey, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
God Bless You my friend.My brother used the same argument with Royalmail and he got a job there be4 he dumped them for institutional racism
Crescencia, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I am coming to the UK to study, and this will open great job opportunities for students and young professionals like me. Ash you my Hero!!!
Pooja, Mumbai around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Does the same thing apply in India ? I saw a good IT job I'd like to go for in Hyderabad.
Tom, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Does the same thing apply in India ? I saw a good IT job I'd like to go for in Hyderabad.
Tom, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I have worked with ash was he working illegaly ? Why as his work permit been revoked OCS actions were correct time to stop carrying visiters
roger, rotherham around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I now this man & may be there is a reason he does not have a work permit.if a visiter does't have a permit he should get his own
roger, rotherham around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
kudos
parixit, mumbai around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I actually have a work permit and got rejected for a job with the FSA simply b/c the permit had an expiry date.
JC, Brentford around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
This case is such an eye opener for al. Mr.Ash, you are indeed intelligent and have shown the true interpretation of the law. Very Well Done
James, Cardiff around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
The concept of Equal Opportunities Employers would mean jobs are open to all nationals via open competition and this case proved it.Wel Done
Tom, Newcastle around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
hey ash, congratulations !! u have made it and make everyone proud of you. All the best mate.
mayank, stoke on trent around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Load of tosh. Employers do not legally have to sponsor a candidate so why waste their time if you do not have a visa to work here.
not racist but this makes me angry., UK around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
The resident market test,does not exclusively encourage local employment,this case shows the need for open competition in UKWell done Mr.Ash
Tom, Cambridge around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
You have brought pride to the Legal profession, and its a shame, other solicitors, and barristers have not been able to see through this.
Anne, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
All I can simply say one thing.He's by far one of the most humble and intelligent person I have met in the legal profession it was an honor.
Anne, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
I had the chance to meet Mr.Ash during his trip to London, and he was kind enough to spare some time to share his views with me.
Anne, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
This does not put any extra burden on any employer(s). The employers have just got the easy way out for so long. Mr. Ash has proven the fact
Anne, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
The resident job market test, is simply requiring employers to advertise jobs locally, and not recruit directly from outside the UK
Anne, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Proud of you!
Nosheen, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
All this does is create work for employers in securing permits for people which is already difficult & against the govt's residency test.
Dan, London around 8 months, 3 weeks ago
Mr.Ash,you have single handedly revealed decades of discrimination practice by employers in UK. Its a honor and privilege to read about you.
John, London around 8 months, 4 weeks ago
especially non EEA Nationals who with their skills and experience are going to surpass some of the UK and EU applicants. So now the its good
John, London around 8 months, 4 weeks ago
This case would still be relevant, as the resident labour market test would still apply and employers are going to look at every applicant
John, London around 8 months, 4 weeks ago
This is a warning for employers who have used work permits as an excuse to reject nonEEA candidates, they better get their act together.
Nicky, London around 9 months ago
congratulations tinu bhaiya..... :-)
shibani bohra, mumbai around 9 months ago
Why such blanket ban was imposed on such deserving people is beyond anyone’s imagination.
Nishikant, Sheffield around 9 months ago
These non-EEA students who came all the way from their countries, paying thousands of pounds in form of fees, helping the local economy.
Nishikant, Sheffield around 9 months ago
because of such intentional discrimination shrouded in cover of Home office and Border Security.
Nishikant, Sheffield around 9 months ago
This will certainly strengthen all legally eligible and brilliant non-EEA candidates who were deprived of lawful employment
Nishikant, Sheffield around 9 months ago
Well begun is half done already! It will be a boon for the new candidates, all thanks to your great work... Keep at it. God Bless
harleen, sheffield around 9 months ago
Its surprising to see what law firms have been practicing and advising for the past few decades was infact discriminating thats embarassing.
Chris, London around 9 months ago
I knew it was not right, however, you are the only one Mr.Purohit to break through the barrier single handedly. Hats off to you. Impressive.
Tasha, Manchester around 9 months ago
Brilliant work Mr.Ash, this opens new avenues for all nonEEA Nationals. Wonder how the companies got away in UK discriminating since so long
Ben , London around 9 months ago
And never forget that you have given a million people a chance for a better future. You did it!
Parul Shah, Mumbai around 9 months ago
May your life be as full of success as a barn is full of hay, as Maggi noodleshas starch, as cheese is yummy :) Proud of you my friend! muah
Parul Shah, Mumbai around 9 months ago
hello ashok bhaiya congratulation's you are the one for whom i can b proud of.best of luck for ur further work. bye (love from all)
reetika, jodhpur around 9 months ago
hi ash congrats .you did a great job
gopal kalla, jodhpur around 9 months ago


Post a comment






Alert me of replies

You have characters left


 









Latest Business












Powered by Click Creative
© All Rights Reserved.